Click here to visit Classifieds
Click for ZooMed
Click here to visit Classifieds

Sound Off: Petite woman who bagged ancient gator

By Cindy Steinle · September 22, 2010 2:28 pm

Last week, the story of a petite woman who went to South Carolina and bagged herself a monster alligator in a guided hunt made the national news. The popularity of the show "Swamp People" has alligator hunting on people's minds, too. I would really like to hear what our community thinks about the alligator hunting story. I understand the need to cull the herd and keep populations viable and in check. I have been a member of the NRA and regularly mooch my share of fall venison off folks. I have also eaten alligator. Something just doesn't sit right with this story, however; it reminds me of the violence of a bull fight. From GrindTV.com:
Afterward, however, some people became outraged by the methods used to dispatch the great reptile: baited fishing lines, followed by harpoons, a muzzle snare, shots from a .22-caliber weapon and, ultimately, a knife jab to the spinal cord. "This woman should be in jail, not on TV," was among the tamer comments posted beneath a story on Carolinalive.com. "They tortured that alligator for hours. That's just plain sick," a Bostonherald.com reader chimed in.
The video supplied by the AP is after the bump. What do you think?

Comments

paul Sep 22, 2010

It's all about methods. Hunting deer isn't always the most sporting thing ever (feeding stations? C'mon). And I just don't know how they did the hunt.

Oddly though some of the less humane methods (spear hunting for instance) are more sporting in that it's harder to get the animal and you're up for more of a fight...it's got a better chance of getting away and/or harming you than it does if you're using a rifle or bow.

Chris Sep 22, 2010

That gator didn't do anything to deserve to be tortured and killed. I can't understand how or why someone can be so cruel. Gators aren't evil monsters out to eat people. The question I have for the lady that killed that gator is "Why couldn't you have just left him alone?" Because of what she did that's one less beautiful animal for us to enjoy.

Linda Sep 22, 2010

a gator of that size is a rare find. Wouldn't it have been better to take photos of the gator. What was HUMANE about any part of that hunt and kill?

Richie Sep 22, 2010

SICKENING!!!!!! This animal survived the hardships of the wild long enough to reach that size only to meet it's demise by being tortured and killed with no respect by some dopey bitch out for a thrill. An animal that size is a find and a treasure and should have been preserved. It's ignorant people that should be culled.

Peter Sep 22, 2010

Stupid bitch. What's the point? her 2 minutes of fame?

paul Sep 22, 2010

So...are all of ya'll anti-hunting in general?

Dean Ripa Sep 22, 2010

There was another guy on the web recently that killed another big brute like that. They should get married and commit suicide.

Cindy Steinle Sep 22, 2010

Actually I am not. I do not hunt, but that is primarily because I am a klutz and I hate the cold. I do find issue with numerous ways to kill the gator.

I live in hunting country, I believe in hunting as a sustainable meat solution, but I see nothing good in killing to kill. I follow the ways of the nug. :)

Carrie Sep 22, 2010

While I'm not against hunting, and understand the need to control populations of certain animals, I still think THIS particular act was wrong. I think that they should be "killed" humanely as possible.

And also...that poor gator was 13-feet long. He had lived a long life, and deserved to finish it out. It's so hard for gators to survive to those lengths! I feel sorry for him.

Richie Sep 22, 2010

Absolutely not. I believe if you kill it you should eat it. Hunting purely for sport or the thrill of the kill is what I'm against. In most cases hunting is necessary to control natural animal populations but there is a right way and a wrong way to do things. This gator was senselessly tortured and killed for no good reason.

Add a comment

https://www.crepnw.com/
Click here to visit Classifieds
Click to visit Brass Man Reptiles
Site Tools